In what may go down as one of the more bewildering moments of this Supreme Court term, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson stunned legal observers during oral arguments in Louisiana v. Callais by offering this legal gem: “Just trust me on this.” That’s not a paraphrase. That’s a direct quote from a Supreme Court Justice—offered in the middle of a constitutional argument about race-based redistricting.
The case in question concerns a challenge to Louisiana’s congressional map after a lower court ordered the creation of a second majority-black district, citing potential “vote dilution” under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act. The plaintiffs claim the current map weakens black voters’ influence; the challengers argue that the newly drawn district constitutes an unconstitutional racial gerrymander.
But Justice Jackson’s line of argument—if it can be called that—took things in an unexpected and deeply problematic direction.
— Cernovich (@Cernovich) October 15, 2025
Citing the Americans with Disabilities Act, Jackson likened the experience of black voters in majority-white districts to disabled individuals facing physical barriers to public buildings. Her reasoning? That systemic disadvantages exist regardless of intent and should be remedied accordingly.
The analogy is, frankly, absurd.
Yes, the ADA requires accommodations for individuals with physical impairments, but that’s categorically different from using race as the controlling factor in drawing congressional maps. One is about individual access to a public facility; the other is about mandating political outcomes based on race—an area the Court has ruled must pass the highest standard of constitutional scrutiny.
A person born without the ability to walk is not the same as a person born black in the United States. That’s not a commentary on hardship—it’s a fact of law, biology, and logic. The two are not constitutionally interchangeable.
But Jackson didn’t stop there. She repeatedly interrupted Louisiana Solicitor General Ben Aguiñaga, who somehow maintained composure while trying to explain that if a state is going to draw maps using race as a predominant factor, it must meet the constitutional standard of a “compelling government interest”—a position the Court has consistently upheld.
Jackson didn’t seem interested in that. She insisted that proving “intentional discrimination” wasn’t necessary, and when challenged on the constitutional implications of using race in redistricting, she bluntly cut off Aguiñaga with a sarcastic, “Thank you!”
So much for judicial impartiality.







